Paul Oberjuerge header image 2

As a Fan, Ruined for Life

June 26th, 2008 · 3 Comments · Dodgers, Sports Journalism

How many times can this hit home? Probably not until I stop going to live sports events.

I am not a sports fan. Not of any team. Not of any individual. And never again will be.

At least, not in a fashion that would be recognized as fandom by actual sports fans.

Why? Because I was in journalism too long. And traditional fan-like behavior — cheering, applauding, ticket-purchasing, jersey-buying — was leeched out of me during my career. Not that I ever was going to be a fanatic, frothing and screaming. But for me, now, to sit in the stands among other fans … it’s like being the atheist at a spiritual revival.

Some of this is learned behavior. You work in sports journalism, practically the first thing you’re told is, “No cheering in the press box.”

At first, it might be a little tricky to live up to. Eventually, it becomes innate. You sit when others stand. You don’t make a peep when others are shouting. You study a scene impassively while others are celebrating. That’s being professional.

But then this other concept takes root, as well.

You’ve seen too much. You know too much.

You understand just how imperfect is the guy who pitched the perfect game. You have seen the superstar in eclipse. You know his dark side.

You’ve seen teams treat players callously. You know the owner is a cretin and the general manager a dope and the coach/manager a fraud.

It can’t help but jade you. It has to turn you into a cynic. Yeah, nice play, but that kid is an idiot. I’ve talked to him. Clever play, considering that guy is a stoner.

Fans are at a safe remove. In the stands. On the other side of the TV screen. Their contact with athletes is fleeting and limited, allowing them to create heroic (and mythic) figures out of people who are every bit as human and fallible as the people you really do know.

Journalism tends to make cynics of most of us. But the effect seems pronounced in sports journalism, a field where nearly everyone enters as a fan and exits as a jock-world weary unbeliever.

You retain an ability to watch and appreciate competition. Very much so. But even then, you find yourself dissecting it rather than celebrating it. Again, I am reminded of religion. Of how many of the leaders of organized religion eventually become disdainful of it. In their own field, they know the “great and powerful Oz” is just a man manipulating machines from behind a curtain.

Same deal for sports journalists.

The trigger for this bit of self-realization was the Dodgers’ game vs. the White Sox on Wednesday night. My childhood chum, Frankie Poturica, invited me to go along with him, and we sat in a couple of good seats down the first-base line, on the loge (second) level. Where I was surrounded by fans. And why wouldn’t I be?

I was reminded that actual fans cheer and shout and stand up and clap. And all of that just wasn’t going to happen for me. I don’t do that. I looked up at the press box … where the impartial observers were sitting stoically. I am still one of them, and always will be, even while sitting in Seat 5, Row L, Section 140.

I’m glad I went, grateful that Frankie Poturica invited me. I enjoy watching a game. Even if my behavior might seem a bit abnormal, to the crowd.

There’s a sense of something being lost … but with no regret. There is a realization that knowledge has killed some potential for joy … but you won’t give back that knowledge.

It must be fun to be able to forget the real world for a bit, when you’re in the stadium/arena. I can see that it appears to be fun for lots of people. For fans. But I no longer have the need or ability to join in … I realize anew.

Tags:

3 responses so far ↓

  • 1 J.P. Hoornstra // Jun 26, 2008 at 10:33 AM

    Funny, I went to the game too. I sat in the right-field all-you-can-eat section, for the purpose of sitting in the right-field all-you-can-eat section. I went with a bunch of UCLA people and we did the 8-clap (perhaps you heard it at the end of the seventh-inning stretch; perhaps not).

    It was my first baseball game as a spectator this year, and the 8-clap was the highlight of the game.

  • 2 Doug Padilla // Jun 26, 2008 at 11:11 AM

    That would explain the PaulO sighting that was reported back to me the other day. Couldn’t stay away from the press box, could you? Even if it was for only a second. Could have said hello.

  • 3 Damian // Jun 26, 2008 at 5:34 PM

    Paulo,

    I know what you’re saying about holding a certain level of contempt for players on your favorite team because you know a little more about them than most, but hopefully as more time goes by (a few years maybe), you’ll learn to find a new, or repaired appreciation as a fan.

    I held the same view of some guys on my teams but I found something that works — block out the aspect of trying to care for or get to know these guys as individuals and let them serve you the sole purpose of winning games for your team. Make your focus as a fan all about the team, not the player(s). It could take some time.

    I know all the ridiculous, immature, selfish and criminal things Kobe has done and I’m not apologizing for him, but I’ve trained myself to be a big Kobe fan because of his sheer basketball talent and ability, because he can ball like no other and his success directly translates to the success of the Lakers.

    Don’t base your Dodgers experiences on whether you can become a fan again. The Dodgers are so lame and pathetic that they don’t inspire or excite anyone. Anytime your clean-up hitter is something like 43 years old and your manager (someone who doesn’t even play) is your most marketable asset tells you all you need to know about the Dodgers’ fortunes.

    As an Angels fan going to the Freeway series tomorrow, I hope to feast on the Dodgers’ shortcomings.

    Infact, based on their monetary resources, tradition, historical stature and popularity within their sport, one could make the argument that the Dodgers are the most underachieving major sports franchise in America in the last 20 years.

    Thanks for the gift of Scioscia.

Leave a Comment