I always was a fan of Edgar Martinez, Seattle Mariners DH. He looked like a really regular guy, and generally acted like one, too, but he tended to hit what appeared to be an almost effortless .320, .330 with 40 doubles and 80-plus RBI, in years he wasn’t hurt.
Now, Edgar is up for Hall of Fame consideration, having been out of uniform for five years now. And the Seattle Mariners are campaigning for him. Hard.
At the bottom of this post I will append the reams of stats and notes they have sent me pertaining to Edgar. I have a Hall vote, after covering ball for three-plus decades. So that’s why the Mariners clogged my inbox with the statbook I will add later.
I have two issues with Edgar Martinez that I have to resolve before I can support him, and all the numbers and verbiage the Mariners have mustered doesn’t help me. If anything, it reminds me that they did not answer these questions:
1. Does any player who spent most of his career as a designated hitter … belong in the Hall?
Doesn’t that make you half a player? Your defense is so bad (or you are so slow, or you’re so fragile or busted up) that they can’t even hide you out in left field.
Think of all the guys who played before the DH rule whose careers as regulars ended the moment they couldn’t handle the leather. Edgar, meanwhile, did four seasons and change at third base, then went to DH for the final decade-plus of his career. His “counting” numbers totals would be feeble if he hadn’t been able to DH.
It isn’t Martinez’s fault that he got hurt … but don’t we have to consider where he fits in, in the context of baseball history?
(And, by the way, the “do DH’s belong” argument has never really been resolved. Martinez’s candidacy should give us an idea of what the electorate thinks, with Jim Thome and David Ortiz, etc., coming up in the not-so-distant future.)
2. Down below, you can wade through the reams of info the Mariners have sent along, but not until you are near the end of it all will you come across what I consider to be some very important numbers.
Edgar Martinez’s MVP voting record.
Even though he often was described as “the best right-handed hitter in the game” … Martinez finished in the top five in the American League MVP voting only once, a third in 1995. He was sixth in 2000, and in only three other seasons did he get any mention at all in the MVP balloting — 12th in 1992, 14th in 1997, 16th in 2001.
The Mariners attempt to explain this away by saying his support was “splintered” by votes for teammates such as Randy Johnson, Alex Rodriguez, Ken Griffey Jr., Ichiro Suzuki … and even Jay Buhner, Bret Boone and Mike Cameron.
Instead, what that suggests to me is that the MVP voters, who watched ball every day in those seasons, didn’t think Martinez was even the best player on his own team. And how often does a guy not-even-the-best-on-his-team (aside from, perhaps, 1995) … get into the Hall?
Again, I like Edgar. The pudge and the gap power (he never hit more than 37 homers, but had at least 30 doubles nine times) in an era that was rotten with ‘roided up guys with ridiculous homer spikes … well, I like that Edgar either didn’t juice — or wasn’t very good at it. He wasn’t all cut and defined, and he didn’t launch monster homers.
But I will have to think, hard, about the DH thing … and about whether the second- or third- or fourth-best player on the Mariners deserves to be in the Hall.
OK, now the mountain of stuff from the Mariners PR department. Enjoy.
EDGAR MARTINEZ: HALL OF FAME CANDIDATE
At the end of the 2004 baseball season, Edgar Martinez announced his retirement after 18 years in the Major Leagues, all with one team - the Seattle Mariners. One of baseball’s best hitters, Edgar is a first-time candidate on the 2009-2010 ballot for the National Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, NY.
Edgar became the Mariners regular third baseman in 1990 at the age of 27. In his first three seasons, he proved to be a good defensive third baseman and was the 1992 AL batting champion, the first of his two league batting titles. Injuries limited him in 1993 and 1994, and as a result, he played primarily as a designated hitter the rest of his career.
Edgar was very simply one of the top all-around hitters of his era as well as in baseball history. He combined power (best exemplified by his slugging percentage) with the ability to reach base safely (among the best in on-base percentage), both at rates that rank high on the all-time lists of Hall of Fame hitters.
The Mariners organization is proud to provide for your consideration the information below which is intended to present Edgar’s outstanding career accomplishments and put them into historical perspective.
[Edgar’s career Major League statistics are listed at the end of this document. All statistics and notes are from baseball’s modern era (since 1901), and percentages are based on a minimum of 3,000 plate appearances. Hall of Famers are bold and active players are in italics.]
EDGAR MARTINEZ: BATTING TITLES AND AWARDS…
* 2 American League Batting Titles: 1992 (.343) and 1995 (.356)
* 3 American League On-Base Percentage Titles: 1995 (.479), 1998 (.429), 1999 (.447)
* 5 Silver Slugger Awards: 1992, 1995, 1997, 2001, 2003
* 5 Designated Hitter of the Year Awards: 1995, 1997, 1998, 2000, 2001 (now the Edgar Martinez Award)
* 6 Top-10 finishes in American League in Slugging Percentage: 1992, 1995, 1996, 1997, 2000, 2001
* 7 All-Star Game Appearances: 1992, 1995, 1996, 1997, 2000, 2001, 2003
* 7 Top-10 finishes in American League in Average: 1990, 1992, 1995, 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999
* 11 Top-10 finishes in AL On-Base Pct: 1990, 1991, 1992, 1995, 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2003
Milestone Batting Titles…Edgar hit .343 in 1992, at the time the highest batting average in the American League by a right-handed hitter since Harvey Kuenn hit .353 with Detroit in 1959…in addition to leading the league in hitting, led in doubles (46), was second in slugging percentage (.544) and fourth in on-base percentage (.404). Martinez won his second batting title in 1995, posting a .356 mark, at the time the highest in the AL by a right-handed hitter since Joe DiMaggio hit .381 in 1939…his ‘95 title made him, at the time, just the seventh right-handed hitter to win two batting titles, the first in the AL since Luke Appling (1936 & 1943)…in 1995, Edgar led the league in average, on-base percentage (.479), runs (121) and doubles (52).
SELECT COMPANY: HITTERS WITH CAREER .300+ - .400+ - .500+ PERCENTAGES
Edgar Martinez is one of 20 players in Major League history to have a lifetime batting average over .300, a lifetime on-base percentage over .400 and a lifetime slugging percentage over .500…of the 12 prior eligible players in this select company, 11 are in the Hall of Fame:
Seasons AVG OBP SLG G R H 2B 3B HR RBI
1 Ty Cobb HOF 1905-1928 (24) .367 .433 .513 3033 2245 4191 724 297 117 1961
2 Rogers Hornsby HOF 1915-1937 (23) .358 .434 .577 2259 1579 2930 541 169 301 1584
3 Joe Jackson 1908-1920 (13) .356 .423 .517 1330 873 1772 307 168 54 785
4. Lefty O’Doul 1919-1934 (11) .349 .413 .532 970 624 1140 175 41 113 542
5 Tris Speaker HOF 1907-1928 (22) .345 .428 .501 2789 1881 3515 793 222 117 1529
6 Ted Williams HOF 1939-1960 (19) .344 .482 .634 2292 1798 2654 525 71 521 1839
7 Babe Ruth HOF 1914-1935 (22) .342 .474 .690 2503 2174 2873 506 136 714 2213
8 Harry Heilmann HOF 1914-1932 (17) .342 .410 .520 2146 1291 2660 542 151 183 1539
9 Lou Gehrig HOF 1923-1939 (17) .340 .447 .632 2164 1888 2721 534 163 493 1995
10 Albert Pujols 2001-current (9) .334 .427 .628 1399 1071 1717 387 14 366 1112
11 Stan Musial HOF 1941-1963 (22) .331 .417 .559 3026 1949 3630 725 177 475 1951
12 Todd Helton 1997-current (13) .328 .427 .567 1812 1222 2134 509 34 325 1202
13 Jimmie Foxx HOF 1925-1945 (20) .325 .428 .609 2317 1751 2646 458 125 534 1922
14 Hank Greenberg HOF 1930-1947 (13) .313 .412 .605 1394 1051 1628 379 71 331 1276
15 Manny Ramirez 1993-current (17) .313 .411 .591 2207 1506 2494 531 20 546 1788
16 Larry Walker 1989-2005 (17) .313 .400 .565 1988 1355 2160 471 62 383 1311
17 Edgar Martinez 1987-2004 (18) .312 .418 .515 2055 1219 2247 514 15 309 1261
18 Chipper Jones 1993-current (16) .307 .406 .541 2166 1458 2406 472 37 426 1445
19 Mel Ott HOF 1926-1947 (22) .304 .414 .533 2730 1859 2876 488 72 511 1860
20 Frank Thomas 1990-2008 (19) .301 .419 .555 2322 1494 2468 495 12 521 1704
VERY SELECT COMPANY:
HITTERS WITH CAREER .300+ AVG, .400+ OBP, 300+ HR, 500+ 2B, 1,000+ BB
Edgar Martinez is one of only eight players (listed below) in Major League history to have collected 300+ HR, 500+ doubles, 1000+ walks, boast an average over .300 and an on-base percentage over .400. All five (of these eight) players who are eligible for the Hall of Fame have been inducted in Cooperstown. The other two are still active. Edgar finished his career with 2247 hits, 514 doubles, 1283 walks, 309 home runs, a .312 career batting average and a .418 career on-base percentage.
PLAYER H 2B BB HR AVG OBP
Stan Musial HOF 3630 725 1599 475 .331 .417
Rogers Hornsby HOF 2930 541 1038 301 .358 .434 RH
Babe Ruth HOF 2873 506 2062 714 .342 .474
Lou Gehrig HOF 2721 535 1508 493 .340 .447
Ted Williams HOF 2654 525 2021 521 .344 .482
Manny Ramirez 2494 531 1283 546 .313 .411 RH
Edgar Martinez 2247 514 1283 309 .312 .418 RH
Todd Helton 2134 509 1130 325 .328 .427
ON-BASE PERCENTAGE AND EDGAR MARTINEZ
ON-BASE PERCENTAGE:
* Edgar Martinez ranks 18th on the all-time list with a career OBP of .418.
* Of the 17 players with a higher on-base percentage, 10 are in the Hall of Fame, 2 are still active, 2 are retired but not yet eligible, 2 are not in the HOF and Joe Jackson is banned from baseball.
1. Ted Williams HOF .482 8. Tris Speaker HOF .428 15. Mickey Mantle HOF .421
2. Babe Ruth HOF .474 9. Todd Helton .427 16. Mickey Cochrane HOF .419
3. Lou Gehrig HOF .447 10. Albert Pujols .427 17. Frank Thomas .419
4. Barry Bonds .444 11. Eddie Collins HOF .424 18. Edgar Martinez .418
5. Rogers Hornsby HOF .434 12. Ferris Fain .424 19. Stan Musial HOF .417
6. Ty Cobb HOF .433 13. Max Bishop .423 20. Wade Boggs HOF .415
7. Jimmie Foxx HOF .428 14. Joe Jackson .423 21. Mel Ott HOF .414
BEST ON-BASE PERCENTAGE SEASONS: As noted earlier, Edgar Martinez won a pair of AL batting titles (1992 & 1995). Edgar also led the AL in on-base percentage three times (.479 in 1995, .429 in 1998 and .447 in 1999) and finished in the top 10 seven other seasons in his career.
TOP ON-BASE PERFORMANCES SINCE WORLD WAR II: Among retired players since 1945 with at least 7,500 plate appearances, Edgar Martinez is one of only four players with a career on-base percentage of at least .418 (also: Barry Bonds, Mickey Mantle and Frank Thomas) and one of only eight players with a career batting average of at least .312 (also: Tony Gwynn, Wade Boggs, Rod Carew, Stan Musial, Kirby Puckett, Roberto Clemente and Larry Walker).
OPS (ON-BASE + SLUGGING PERCENTAGE) AND EDGAR MARTINEZ
* Edgar Martinez ranks 32nd on the all-time list with a career OPS of .933.
* Among every player in modern Major League history, Martinez ranks 32nd in OPS; on the All-Time OPS list, the only players ahead of Edgar who are eligible for the Hall of Fame, but not inducted, are Mark McGwire and Lefty O’Doul.
* Edgar recorded an OPS above 1.000 in five seasons (1995-97, 1999-2000); had an OPS above .900 in nine seasons (1987, 1992, 1995-2001); and above .800 in 14 seasons (1987, 1990-92, 1994-2003).
1. Babe Ruth HOF 1.163 (14) 18. Alex Rodriguez .965 RH (6)
2. Ted Williams HOF 1.115 (18) 19. Ryan Howard .961 (1)
3. Lou Gehrig HOF 1.079 (13) 20. Jim Thome .960 (5)
4. Albert Pujols 1.054 RH (7) 21. Johnny Mize HOF .959 (5)
5. Barry Bonds 1.051 (15) 22. Vladimir Guerrero .954 RH (3)
6. Jimmie Foxx HOF 1.037 RH (10) 23. Jeff Bagwell .948 RH (5)
7. Hank Greenberg HOF 1.016 RH (7) 24. Mel Ott HOF .947 (7)
8. Rogers Hornsby HOF 1.010 RH (9) 25. Chipper Jones .946 B (6)
9. Manny Ramirez 1.001 RH (8) 26. Ty Cobb HOF .946 (8)
10. Todd Helton .993 (5) 27. Ralph Kiner HOF .945 RH (3)
11. Mark McGwire .982 RH (7) 28. Lefty O’Doul .945 (2)
12. Mickey Mantle HOF .977 B (8) 29. Willie Mays HOF .941 RH (5)
13. Joe DiMaggio HOF .977 RH (5) 30. Joe Jackson .940 (5)
14. Stan Musial HOF .975 (9) 31. Hack Wilson HOF .939 RH (2)
15. Frank Thomas .974 RH (7) 32. Edgar Martinez .933 RH (5)
16. Lance Berkman .967 B (3) 33. Albert Belle .933 RH (4)
17. Larry Walker .965 (6) (numbers in parenthesis are seasons with OPS over 1.000)
* Other notables on the all-time OPS list include Harry Heilmann (.930), Tris Speaker (.929), Hank Aaron (.928) and Frank Robinson (.926). Other active players include David Ortiz (.922), Ken Griffey Jr. (.912) and Gary Sheffield (.907).
* Edgar has a career OPS+ of .147 tied for 39th all time with Willie Stargell, Mike Schmidt, Alex Rodriguez and Lance Berkman…a 100 OPS+ is considered league average…each point above 100 represents a percentage point; thus Edgar is 47% better than average over his career…OPS+ is a statistic that measures a player’s OPS against the league average, and adjusted for ballpark factors.
AMONG THE BEST HITTERS TO PLAY THE GAME
Edgar’s career batting average: .312 Rank 71st
Edgar’s career on-base percentage: .418 Rank 18th
Edgar’s career slugging percentage: .515 Rank 68th
Edgar’s career OPS: .933 Rank 32nd
DEFINING A POSITION: THE EDGAR MARTINEZ OUTSTANDING DESIGNATED HITTER AWARD
On October 2, 2004, during a retirement ceremony at Safeco Field, Commissioner Bud Selig announced that Major League Baseball had renamed the annual Outstanding Designated Hitter Award the Edgar Martinez Outstanding Designated Hitter Award. Edgar was a five-time winner (1995, 1997, 1998, 2000, 2001) of the award during his career.
Edgar Martinez has the highest career batting average, on-base percentage and OPS (OBP + SLG) of any player as a designated hitter (minimum: 1000 G). As a DH, he also has the most RBI and doubles; and ranks 3rd in home runs.
HIGHEST AVG as DH MOST HR as DH MOST RBI as DH
Edgar Martinez .314 David Ortiz 274 Edgar Martinez 1003
Paul Molitor .308 Frank Thomas 269 Harold Baines 978
Hal McRae .295 Edgar Martinez 243 David Ortiz 900
Harold Baines .291 Harold Baines 235 Frank Thomas 881
David Ortiz .284 Don Baylor 219 Hal McRae 808
HIGHEST OBP as DH HIGHEST OPS as DH MOST 2B as DH
Edgar Martinez .428 Edgar Martinez .959 Edgar Martinez 370
Frank Thomas .394 David Ortiz .936 Hal McRae 357
Chili Davis .381 Travis Hafner .929 David Ortiz 310
David Ortiz .381 Jim Thome .923 Harold Baines 293
Paul Molitor .374 Frank Thomas .899 Paul Molitor 285
AN HISTORIC SEVEN-YEAR RUN OF OFFENSE
During the 7-year stretch from 1995-2001, Edgar Martinez was a dominant offensive force, hitting .329 with a .446 on-base percentage and a .574 slugging percentage…Edgar also recorded 291 doubles in 1,020 games during the stretch…his average was 5th in the Majors during that span, his slugging was 14th, on-base was 2nd and he led the Majors in doubles…Martinez is one of only four players in history to record a seven-season stretch meeting the following statistical milestones:
* Batting average of at least .325
* On-base Percentage of at least .440
* Slugging Percentage of at least .570
* Hit at least 250 doubles
* Play in at least 1,000 games.
The only players to match these numbers over at least seven consecutive seasons are the following:
Player Years
Lou Gehrig 1925-1938 (14)
Ted Williams 1939-1949 (11)
Todd Helton 1999-2006 (8)
Edgar Martinez 1995-2001 (7)
AMONG THE BEST IN HIS DAY
EDGAR’S PRIME TIME: In 13 seasons from 1991-2003, Edgar Martinez was in the top-25 in every major offensive category, including on-base percentage (2nd/.428), doubles (4th/450) and average (.7th/.318) …here’s a look:
ON-BASE PERCENTAGE BATTING AVERAGE DOUBLES OPS
1. Barry Bonds, .462 1. Tony Gwynn, .347 1. Craig Biggio, 466 1. Barry Bonds, 1.116
2. Edgar Martinez, .428 2. Todd Helton, .337 2. John Olerud, 458 2. Mark McGwire, 1.043
3. Frank Thomas, .428 3. Nomar Garciaparra, .323 3. Jeff Bagwell, 455 3. Todd Helton, 1.041
4. Todd Helton, .425 Vladimir Guerrero, .323 4. Edgar Martinez, 450 4. Manny Ramirez, .1.010
5. Brian Giles, .417 5. Larry Walker, 321 5. Luis Gonzalez, 428 5. Frank Thomas, .996
6. Jason Giambi, .415 6. Mike Piazza, .319 Mark Grace, 428 6. Larry Walker, .986
7. Mark McGwire, .414 7. Edgar Martinez, .318 7. Rafael Palmeiro, 425 7. Brian Giles, .980
8. Manny Ramirez, .413 8. Derek Jeter, .317 8. Roberto Alomar, 420 8. Jim Thome, .979
9. Gary Sheffield, .412 Manny Ramirez, .317 9. Frank Thomas, 417 9. Vladimir Guerrero, .978
10. Jeff Bagwell, 411 10. Paul Molitor, .316 Larry Walker, 417 10. Edgar Martinez, .967
Jim Thome, .411
THE MARK OF OFFENSIVE CONSISTENCY: In the 12 seasons between 1990 and 2001, Edgar Martinez was healthy enough to play 90 or more games 10 times. In those 10 seasons, Edgar hit .300 or better every year…In total in the 12 seasons from 1990-2001, Edgar hit a combined .321 with a .429 on-base percentage and a .537 slugging percentage…his OPS was .966, with 1,043 walks compared to 983 strikeouts.
Since the 1940’s, Edgar is one of just six hitters who batted .320 in at least six straight seasons. The others are Stan Musial, Wade Boggs, Rod Carew, Tony Gwynn and Todd Helton.
In the 1990’s, Edgar is one of just seven hitters to post an OPS above 1.000 in four or more seasons. The others were Barry Bonds (8); Mark McGwire & Frank Thomas (6); Edgar Martinez, Albert Belle, Jeff Bagwell and Ken Griffey Jr. (4).
A TRUE SEATTLE MARINER
Through 2009, Edgar Martinez ranks second on the Mariners all-time list in batting average, first in on-base percentage, second in slugging percentage; and leads the franchise in at-bats, runs scored, hits, doubles, walks and he’s second in home runs.
* Edgar Martinez Drive: On March 5, 2005, the section of Atlantic Street South that runs along the south side of Safeco Field was designated as “Edgar Martinez Drive South” by then Seattle Mayor Greg Nickels.
* The Double: Edgar is perhaps best remembered for his performance in the 1995 American League Division Series against the New York Yankees in which he hit .571 and was on base 18 times in 5 games. In Game 4 of that series, he hit a three-run homer, then a grand slam home run that gave the Mariners a 10-6 lead en route to an 11-8 victory. His 7 RBI in that game set a single-game postseason record. The win knotted the best-of-five series at two games apiece and forced Game 5. Down 5-4 in the 11th inning of that decisive game, Martinez hit a two-run double, called simply “The Double” by Mariners fans, off Jack McDowell, scoring Joey Cora and Ken Griffey Jr. to win the game for the Mariners, 6-5.
* Mariners Hall of Fame: Was inducted into the Seattle Mariners Hall of Fame on June 2, 2007, just the third player honored in team history.
WALKS, DOUBLES AND HOME RUNS
POWER AND PATIENCE: Edgar Martinez collected four 100+ walk seasons (1995-98)…he had eight 90+ walk seasons (1995-2001, 2003) including the four 100 walk campaigns…for his career, walked 1,283 times in 8,672 plate appearances (14.79%)…had more walks than strikeouts in 10 different seasons and finished his career with more walks than K’s (1,283 career walks, 1,202 career strikeouts)…AMONG PLAYERS WITH 300 or MORE HOMERS, IS ONE OF JUST 28 PLAYERS WITH MORE WALKS THAN STRIKEOUTS…of the 28 players, 21 are eligible for the Hall of Fame and 18 are members:
Player Walks Homers Strikeouts Player Walks Homers Strikeouts
Barry Bonds 2558 762 1539 Chipper Jones 1343 426 1231
Babe Ruth HOF 2062 714 1330 Edgar Martinez 1283 309 1202
Ted Williams HOF 2021 521 709 Al Kaline HOF 1277 399 1020
Carl Yastrzemski HOF 1845 452 1393 Todd Helton 1130 325 883
Mickey Mantle HOF 1733 536 1710 George Brett HOF 1096 317 908
Mel Ott HOF 1708 511 896 Rogers Hornsby HOF 1038 301 679
Frank Thomas 1667 521 1397 Ralph Kiner HOF 1011 369 749
Darrell Evans 1605 414 1410 Rocky Colavito 951 374 880
Stan Musial HOF 1599 475 696 Johnny Mize HOF 856 359 524
Lou Gehrig HOF 1508 493 790 Hank Greenberg HOF 852 331 844
Gary Sheffield 1475 509 1171 Albert Pujols 811 366 570
Jimmie Foxx HOF 1452 534 1311 Joe DiMaggio HOF 790 361 369
Hank Aaron HOF 1402 755 1383 Yogi Berra HOF 704 358 414
Rafael Palmeiro 1353 569 1348 Chuck Klein HOF 601 300 521
50 - 500 DOUBLES: Edgar Martinez recorded his 500th career double May 7, 2004 vs. New York, becoming just the 39th player in modern baseball history to collect 500 doubles…he finished his career with 514…Martinez collected 20 or more doubles in 11 consecutive years (1994-2004), and in 14 of his final 15 seasons (1990-92; 1994-04; limited to 7 doubles in 42 games played in 1993 by injuries).
Edgar is one of just four hitters with back-to-back seasons (52 each in 1995 and 1996) with more than 50 doubles in history. The others are George Burns (1926-27), Billy Herman (1935-36) and Joe Medwick (1936-37).
Most Career Doubles
35. Ted Williams HOF 525
36. Willie Mays HOF 523
37. Ken Griffey Jr.-A 522
Ed Delahanty HOF 522
39. Garrett Anderson-A 516
40. Joe Cronin HOF 515
41. Edgar Martinez 514
42. Mark Grace 511
43. Rickey Henderson HOF 510
ALSO NOTEWORTHY…
* 4-time Sporting News All-Star: 1992, 1995, 1997, 2001
* AL Player of the Month 5 Times: July 1992, Aug. 1992, June 1995, May 2000, May 2003
* AL Player of the Week 7 Times: 7/8/91; 8/17/92; 6/25/95; 6/16/96; 9/5/99; 5/22/00; 8/5/02
* 2-time Mariners MVP by Seattle Chapter, BBWAA: 1992, 1995
* Set the ALDS Record for Most Hits in a 5-game series with 12 vs. New York in 1995
* Became 1st Player in ML history to collect 7 RBI in a post-season game (Game 4 of 1995 ALDS vs. New York)
* 9 Career Grand Slams (plus one in the post-season)
* 2 Career Three-Homer Games; 19 Career Two-Homer Games
* Boasted a career average over .300 vs. 12 of the 13 other teams in the AL (.294 vs. Boston)
* Was a career .625 hitter (10×16) with 3 doubles, 2 home runs, 6 RBI and 3 walks vs. Mariano Rivera (.700 on-base percentage, 1.188 slugging percentage = 1.888 OPS)
MVP BALLOTING: Had a pair of top-6 finishes in the American League MVP balloting and was five times in the top-16…here’s a look:
* Finished 12th in 1992, despite playing on a last place team, and missing final 3 weeks after having surgery on shoulder.
* Finished 3rd in 1995, despite splitting votes with teammates Jay Buhner (5th) and Randy Johnson (6th).
* Finished 14th in 1997, despite splitting votes with teammates Ken Griffey Jr. (1st) and Randy Johnson (11th).
* Finished 6th in 2000, despite splitting votes with teammate Alex Rodgriguez (3rd).
* Finished 16th in 2001, despite splitting votes with teammates Ichiro Suzuki (1st), Bret Boone (3rd) and Mike Cameron (T16th).
SILVER SLUGGER AWARDS: Edgar Martinez won five Silver Slugger Awards (1992, 1995, 1997, 2001 & 2003) making him one of just 26 players in history with five or more…Edgar is one of just 16 non-outfielders to win five or more Silver Slugger Awards…Edgar won one when he was predominantly a third baseman (1992) and four when he was predominantly a designated hitter.
# of Silver Sluggers - Player (position)
12- Barry Bonds (OF)
10- Mike Piazza (C), Alex Rodriguez (SS-7, 3B-3),
9 - Barry Larkin (SS),
8 - Wade Boggs (3B), Cal Ripken Jr. (SS), Manny Ramirez (OF),
7 - Albert Belle (OF), Ken Griffey Jr. (OF), Vladimir Guerrero (OF), Tony Gwynn (OF), Ivan Rodriguez (C), Ryan Sandberg (2B),
6 - Juan Gonzalez (OF), Lance Parris (C), Kirby Puckett (OF), Mike Schmidt (3B), Sammy Sosa (OF),
5 - Edgar Martinez (3B-1, DH-4), Albert Belle (OF), Craig Biggio (C-1, 2B-4), Gary Carter (C), Julio Franco (2B-4, DH-1), Mike
Hampton (P), Jorge Posada (C), Dave Winfield (OF)
IN THE COMMUNITY
Following the 2004 season, Edgar received the Roberto Clemente Award, the MLB award that recognizes the player who combines a dedication to giving back to the community with outstanding skills on the baseball field. Martinez was the first Puerto Rican player to win the award.
In 2007 Edgar was inducted to the World Sports Humanitarian Hall of Fame along with Dikembe Mutombo (NBA) and Kyle Petty (NASCAR). This Hall of Fame, located in Boise, ID, recognizes individuals and organizations from the world of amateur and pro athletics who, through their humanitarian efforts, distinguish themselves as role models in the community.
EDGAR MARTINEZ YEAR-BY-YEAR…
YEAR AVG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS OBP SLG OPS
1987 .372 13 43 6 16 5 2 0 5 2 5 0 0 .413 .581 .994
1988 .281 14 32 0 9 4 0 0 5 4 7 0 0 .351 .406 .758
1989 .240 65 171 20 41 5 0 2 20 17 26 2 1 .314 .304 .619
1990 .302 144 487 71 147 27 2 11 49 74 62 1 4 .397 .433 .830
1991 .307 150 544 98 167 35 1 14 52 84 72 0 3 .405 .452 .857
1992 *.343 135 528 100 181 *46 3 18 73 54 61 14 4 .404 .544 .948
1993 .237 42 135 20 32 7 0 4 13 28 19 0 0 .366 .378 .744
1994 .285 89 326 47 93 23 1 13 51 53 42 6 2 .387 .482 .869
1995 *.356 *145 511 *121 182 *52 0 29 113 116 87 4 3 *.479 .628 *1.107
1996 .327 139 499 121 163 52 2 26 103 123 84 3 3 .464 .595 1.059
1997 .330 155 542 104 179 35 1 28 108 119 86 2 4 .456 .554 1.009
1998 .322 154 556 86 179 46 1 29 102 106 96 1 1 *.429 .565 .993
1999 .337 142 502 86 169 35 1 24 86 97 99 7 2 *.447 .554 1.001
2000 .324 153 556 100 180 31 0 37 *145 96 95 3 0 .423 .579 1.002
2001 .306 132 470 80 144 40 1 23 116 93 90 4 1 .423 .543 .966
2002 .277 97 328 42 91 23 0 15 59 67 69 1 1 .403 .485 .888
2003 .294 145 497 72 146 25 0 24 98 92 95 0 1 .406 .489 .895
2004 .263 141 486 45 128 23 0 12 63 58 107 1 0 .342 .385 .727
Totals .312 2055 7213 1219 2247 514 15 309 1261 1283 1202 49 30 .418 .515 .933
* Led American League
4 responses so far ↓
1 Danny Summers // Nov 26, 2009 at 9:08 am
Hello PaulO, I will chime in on this one. I am well aware of your like/love/respect for Edgar. You have been in his corner for years. But a Hall of Famer? I say no.
The problem is this. There are a couple of names on the lists that the Mariners emailed you of guys who have great numbers, but are clearly not Hall of Famers — Todd Helton and Larry Walker. If you put Edgar in, you have to put Helton and Walker in — and that is a shame. I live here in Colorado and have seen Todd Helton play for nine seasons — the last five of which the Rockies have been unsuccessfull trying to dump his sorry ass. He is the most overrated player in history. His splits are worse than Dante Bichette’s and Walker’s and Vinny Castilla’s. He had some great numbers when he was on steroids (and yes, he was on steroids) and has fallen off very hard in recent years.
Edgar was a much more valuable player to his team than Helton ever was. And Edgar is not (I am sorry to say) a Hall of Famer.
I am all for putting guys in the Hall who have made a huge impact on the game in a short — or long — amount of time. I am also a huge numbers guy and believe they mean a lot. That’s why I think Biggio should be in there some day. I also think that if Johnny Damon has three or four more productive years he will have the numbers to be a Hall of Famer. Sandy Koufax is in based on five great seasons. The same for Dizzy Dean. But Edgar, as you pointed out, was never the most dominant player on his own team. His all-time numbers are very good, but not great. He never dominated the game as a hitter like Wade Boggs. And he played in a dome — which I think played a part in his success (I would have to see his splits to see how effective he was outside of Seattle).
The Marniners have four furure Hall of Famers from the Edgar years — ARod, Randy Johnson, Griffey, Jr., and Ichiro. Edgar should be on the outside looking in.
2 Jacob Pomrenke // Nov 26, 2009 at 2:24 pm
Just a point of contention to the argument that Edgar wasn’t the best player on his own team — and he wasn’t:
I don’t like the Mariners’ rationale for Martinez’s lack of MVP votes, but playing with Griffey Jr., one of the greatest ever, as his teammate all those years should have little bearing on Martinez’s Hall of Fame candidacy.
I would submit that Willie McCovey, a legit HOFer, was the best player on his team for only a few short years. It also could be argued that Lou Gehrig was only the best player on his team for about 3-4 years.
Bobby Doerr and Eddie Mathews, also legit HOFers, were never the best players on their teams. I think Paul Molitor — who spent a majority of his career as DH, and might be the precedent Edgar needs to get in — was never the best player on his team. And you could say that about a dozen old Yankees of the Ruth or Dimaggio or Mantle eras.
There are several strikes against Martinez’s case. But I don’t think that should be one of them.
3 Dennis Pope // Nov 26, 2009 at 7:42 pm
I’m all for DHs as HOFers. I think players should not be discounted because they were awful defensively and that the best-at-your-position argument (that so often applies to players earning admission to Cooperstown) should also apply to DHs.
All that said, Edgar Martinez is not a Hall of Famer. To Jacob’s point, many of Martinez’s numbers were the by-product of being teammates with Griffey and A-Rod and Buhner and Boone yet he still failed to reach many HOF-type milestones.
For instance, one player Jacob mentions — Paul Molitor — reached 3,000 hits while Martinez would had to have played for four or more healthy, productive seasons to get close to that number. And since he was a DH (or professional hitter) and not, say, a career 3B or 2B, his hit total should REALLY matter. Had he reached even 2,500 his resume would seem a little more attractive.
In summation… No MVPs, No 3,000 (or 2,500) hits, no HOF. Pretty easy.
4 Jim Alexander // Dec 2, 2009 at 7:25 pm
To be honest, I don’t see anybody newly eligible this year that passes the test of, “if you have to ask yourself whether he’s a Hall of Famer, he probably isn’t.”
And have you received the Reds’ campaign materials on Barry Larkin’s behalf yet? This seems to be a trend, and it’s one that I’m a little uncomfortable with. I’ll do my own research for the HOF ballot, thank you very much.
Leave a Comment